- The Frog and Toad Treasury by Arnold Lobel
- Tillie Lays An Egg by Terry Golson
- The Real Hole by Beverly Cleary
- Rikki-Tikki-Tavi by Rudyard Kipling, illustrated by Jerry Pinkney (abridged)
- Are You a Grasshopper? (Backyard Books) by Judy Allen
- The Biggest Dinosaurs by Michael Berenstain
- Big Chickens by Leslie Helakoski
- Are You a Dragonfly? (Backyard Books) by Judy Allen
- Big Chickens Fly the Coop by Leslie Helakoski
- Are You a Butterfly? (Backyard Books) by Judy Allen
- Today Is Monday by Eric Carle
- Fox In Socks by Dr. Seuss
- Becoming Butterflies by Anne Rockwell
- A Day in the Life of Murphy (Bccb Blue Ribbon Picture Book Awards (Awards)) by Alice Provensen
- Roar!: A Noisy Counting Book by Pamela Duncan Edwards
- Dora in the Deep Sea (Dora the Explorer Ready-to-Read) by Christine Ricci (ugh)
- Minnie and Moo: The Case of the Missing Jelly Donut (I Can Read Book 3) by Denys Cazet
- Are You a Ladybug? (Backyard Books) by Judy Allen
- Are You a Bee? (Backyard Books) by Judy Allen
- AlphaOops!: The Day Z Went First by Alethea Kontis
- Into The A, B, Sea: An Ocean Alphabet Book by Deborah Lee Rose
- Do Not Open This Book by Michaela Muntean
- Chickens Aren't the Only Ones (World of Nature Series) by Ruth Heller
- Storm is Coming! by Heather Tekavec
- Little Fox Goes to the End of the World by Ann Tompert
- It Could Always Be Worse: A Yiddish Folk Tale (Michael Di Capua books) by Margot Zemach
- Eric Carle's Animals Animals (selected poems)
- Egg Drop by Mini Grey
- Katy and The Big Snow by Virginia Lee Burton
- Boo and Baa at Sea by Olof Landstrom and Lena Landstrom
- Olive, the Other Reindeer by Vivian Walsh
- Dinosaur Dream by Dennis Nolan
- Dinosaurs Before Dark (Magic Tree House, No. 1) by Mary Pope Osborne *
- The Knight at Dawn (Magic Tree House, No. 2) by Mary Pope Osborne *
- Mouse Soup by Arnold Lobel
- Mummies in the Morning (Magic Tree House, No. 3) by Mary Pope Osborne *
After much searching on the web, I found some leveled reading lists that gave me a place to start. I searched for books that were a bit challenging for First Son when we read them together and pulled ones on the same lists that I knew we had on the shelves or that I'd read and liked from the library.
Then I discovered the Lexile Framework. I can't say whether it's an adequate measure, really, but I have found some helpful suggestions using the Find a Book feature. Again, I searched for books we were already reading, then used the same range to find new books. What I like best about this particular site is the ability to refine the results using scales on the list for not only reading ability, but age. While not everything they think is appropriate for a six year old is something I think is appropriate for my six year old, it's wonderful to be able to eliminate a great many books we all think are inappropriate for him.
Moving forward, I was still very lenient with what First Son selected to read, but I tried to keep a shelf stocked with books I believed were close to a level that would be challenging (with me sitting beside and helping with any difficult words).
- Mercy Watson Fights Crime by Kate DiCamillo
- The Girl Who Loved Wild Horses (Richard Jackson Books (Atheneum Hardcover)) by Paul Goble
- Hot Fudge Hero by Pat Brisson
- Attack of the Tyrannosaurus (Dinosaur Cove, No. 1) by Rex Stone (This was actually a bit too hard when we first read it together.)
- Pirates Past Noon (Magic Tree House, No. 4) by Mary Pope Osborne *
- Night of the Ninjas (Magic Tree House, No. 5) by Mary Pope Osborne *
- Bertie's Picture Day by Pat Brisson
- Midnight on the Moon (Magic Tree House, No. 8) by Mary Pope Osborne * (He read numbers 6 and 7, too, just not during our reading lessons.)
- The Runaway Bunny by Margaret Wise Brown
- Squids Will Be Squids (Picture Puffins) by Jon Scieszka (selected morals)
- Saturday Night at the Dinosaur Stomp by Carol Diggory Shields
- Ghost Town at Sundown (Magic Tree House) by Mary Pope Osborne *
- If I Had a Million Onions by Sheree / Yayo (selected poems)