Up until a couple of weeks ago, Second Daughter did not really like baths. We've had that experience before, so we did what worked last time. We put her in the tub with her brother (and sister).
Now, she loves bath time. We have to keep First Son in the middle because (not surprisingly) First Daughter is a little bit too loving for Second Daughter's comfort. It's a little hectic, but preferable to distressing. In fact, it's pretty fun for Kansas Dad (the usual bath supervisor here on the Range).